[Beowulf] Consumer vs. Enterprise Hard Drives in Clusters

Bill Broadley bill at cse.ucdavis.edu
Tue Jan 27 22:52:25 PST 2009

I found my actual results from a WD consumer 320GB drive (single platter) with
the drive on the bench vs inside a 1U node:



Once the WD320 (a consumer drive) was replaced with a seagate es2 (raid
edition drive):


So while it's dangerous to over generalize, I'd say the seagate ES2 is
dramatically more vibration resistant than the 320GB WD consumer drive I
tested.  My best guess is that is not uncommon, and when I manage to pry a
decent spec sheet out of vendor they do show dramatically different vibration

So while I encourage folks to try the 2TB WD consumer drive in a 48 drive
array and report back, my expectations are low.  Personally I'll wait, I'm
sure both Seagate and WD will ship over 1TB raid editions at some point.

More information about the Beowulf mailing list