[Beowulf] problem of mpich-1.2.7p1
gus at ldeo.columbia.edu
Thu Feb 4 12:09:43 PST 2010
Yes, Mark, you are right.
Passwordless ssh is not a strict requirement,
although it is a simple way to make things work.
Yes, host based trust is better than unencrypted private keys.
I don't even know if the cluster in question is
connected to the Internet, though.
My suggestions were directed to someone who is still using
MPICH-1, claimed to have trouble with it,
not to be familiar to clusters and MPI,
and to have a pressing deadline.
Therefore, I thought it would be more helpful to give him
simple and focused suggestions,
rather than a full gamut of possibilities.
I guess it would be a great help to him if you post
simple instructions (or a link) on how to setup passwordless ssh
through host based trust.
Mark Hahn wrote:
>> In MPICH2 you need to establish passwordless ssh (not rsh!)
>> connection across your machines.
> it should be said that mpich2 doesn't strictly require this.
> all mpi flavors can operate with other spawning methods - some have
> hooks to be spawned by the resource manager, for instance, which
> bypasses ssh/rsh type access.
>> In OpenMPI you also need to establish passwordless ssh connection
> same for OpenMPI: doesn't actually require passwordless ssh.
> but if you do want passwordless ssh, IMO the only sane solution is to
> configure hostbased trust. having an unencrypted private key in your
> home directory is hideous (moral equivalent of putting your password in
> a file, in the clear...)
> Beowulf mailing list, Beowulf at beowulf.org sponsored by Penguin Computing
> To change your subscription (digest mode or unsubscribe) visit
More information about the Beowulf