[Beowulf] SGI to offer Windows on clusters
eric-shook at uiowa.edu
Thu Jan 18 06:53:31 PST 2007
Ashley Pittman wrote:
> On Wed, 2007-01-17 at 08:50 +0100, Mikael Fredriksson wrote:
>> Eric Shook wrote:
>>> I talked to our SGI rep about this yesterday and he told me they are not
>>> really targeting "hard-core" university research where Linux/UNIX
>>> already has a strong foot hold. Instead this is for the Business sector
>>> where simplified workflows and having easy HPC integration into an
>>> already 100% Windows Infrastructure is more appealing.
>>> This was his take and it seemed reasonable to me.
>> Yes, it is. And more so if this cluster/LAN can also utilize som type
>> of "MOSIX" system. This will substatially increase the throughput of
>> "standard serial" processes.
> I find this statement hard to comprehend, how can any OS substantially
> improve throughput of jobs unless what it replaces is incredibly
> deficient in some way? The limiting factor on clusters is the speed of
> the hardware, even if some OS magically manages to be say 50% more
> efficient doing it's bit than another OS it's still only a tiny percent
> of time used, substantial improvements in job throughput can only come
> about from better parallel algorithms, better code or faster hardware.
Actually there are a few case studies floating around comparing Linux to
Windows (not sure about UNIX). That when running on identical hardware
and the same code you can lose up to 30% efficiency running on Windows.
I am too lazy to try to find my supporting evidence but for the last 2
years at SC05/06 there have been such studies on the show floor (I don't
think they made it to the papers/posters section of the conference, so I
cannot comment on the quality of the study).
>> But as stated in a previous thread, the "hard-core" systems are fairly specialized.
> I think you may be surprised if you actually used a hard-core system,
> whilst it's true that they are more than the sum of their parts the
> parts are mostly that of a bog standard Linux distribution.
> I suppose it could be true that changing to OS to Windows would make
> them less specialised however that probably says more about Windows than
> it does about "hard-core" clusters, I've no idea if this statement would
> be true any more however, I've not used Windows in a number of years.
> Beowulf mailing list, Beowulf at beowulf.org
> To change your subscription (digest mode or unsubscribe) visit http://www.beowulf.org/mailman/listinfo/beowulf
Eric Shook (319) 335-6714
Technical Lead, Systems and Operations - GROW
More information about the Beowulf