Archives


- Beowulf
- Beowulf Announce
- Scyld-users
- Beowulf on Debian

[Beowulf] passwordless "rsh" login

Many of your questions may have already been answered in earlier discussions or in the FAQ. The search results page will indicate current discussions as well as past list serves, articles, and papers.

Search

Trent Piepho xyzzy at speakeasy.org
Fri Jul 9 14:17:54 PDT 2004


On Fri, 9 Jul 2004, Robert G. Brown wrote:
> this three or four times.  Things wrong with rsh:
>  a) no security (as in "bleeding wound" in an open network)
>  b) no environment passing
>  c) no tunnelling/port forwarding
>  d) no intrinsic X11 support
>  e) archaic and easily spoofed/snooped authentication mechanism (see a))
>  f) terrible passwordless login control
>  g) more or less frozen, unsupported code

For starting jobs on a cluster with a private network, only b and g really
matter, and then not that much.

> Things good about rsh:
> 
>  h) relatively fast

For passing data over gigabit ethernet, rsh/rcp vs ssh/scp is about four times
faster, depending on the CPU.

> Things bad about ssh:
> 
>  i) relatively slow
>  j) cannot select "no encryption" as option even on secure networks
>  k) evil tty disconnect "feature" that requires ~. escapes (nested yet)
> to leave a job backgrounded from an ssh session.

What is so annoying about these things is that they didn't used to be
problems with ssh.  They were "features" added intentionally.  I cannot
stand the "we know what's best for you" attitude.





More information about the Beowulf mailing list